Departments: Health
Students' Emotional Well-Being After a Crisis
Pediatric psychologist Annette
La Greca from the University of Miami in Coral Gables, Florida, has worked
with students following disaster situations, including in the months and
years following Hurricane Andrew. She spoke with Angela Oddone, MSW, mental
wellness program coordinator for the NEA Health Information Network, about
the psychological impact that terrorism may be having on students.
What do school staff need to know now?
It's important for educators to recognize that children's reactions unfold
over time. An event like this is not something children (or adults) "get
over" quickly, especially for those with high levels of exposure
to the disaster. The process of recovery -- psychologically and otherwise
--will occur very gradually over time.
Beyond initial crisis response, how can school
staff help students recover from this experience?
Maintain a balance between sticking to routines and yet being flexible
within those routines to respond to kids' needs. That will be key in the
weeks and months ahead.
Everyone now is on a fast learning curve in terms of honing their skills
at managing stress. By setting an example, school staff can teach students
how to give themselves and each other time and permission to focus on
the September 11 attacks and all aspects associated with it, including
the psychological aspects. Equally important, however, will be teaching
how to give ourselves and each other permission and opportunities to experience
time off from these events as well.
What do school staff need to know about post-traumatic stress?
Symptoms of post-traumatic stress--for example, difficulties concentrating,
greater irritability-- are normal reactions to an abnormal event. I think
that is the most important thing of all to keep in mind. We may be experiencing
our emotions, our behaviors, and each other in ways that we have never
experienced before.
Although stress symptoms [listed in box, top right] may be disconcerting
to us at times, it is important to understand and remember that they are
normal for a situation such as this one.
How might children's experience of the terrorism
compare with that of adults?
Children can show any of the classic stress symptoms that we adults may
also be experiencing. In particular, it may be helpful for educators to
keep in mind that students may have more difficulty focusing at times.
Changes in students' capacities to concentrate and pay attention may occur
while they are at school and when they are at home in terms of completing
homework assignments.
Some of the changes that we may notice in children will be psychological
in nature. But other significant factors could come into play. For example,
we might predict that a downturn in the economy may mean that some students
will also be having to accommodate other types of adjustments at home,
such as a parent's loss of a job.
We in the adult world are now living in an environment that requires
us to tolerate an uncomfortable degree of uncertainty. The good news for
children and schools is that we can maximize the certainty in children's
lives through the routines they ordinarily experience at school. Those
routines may also be comforting and helpful to school staff as well.
Can we expect measures like standardized test
scores to be affected?
Yes, absolutely. We can expect test scores to be noticeably affected by
the impact that terrorism has had on our country, especially for students
who lost a family member or friend, or those who have close personal ties
to the disaster sites.
From a statistical viewpoint, in some school districts, it may not be
meaningful to compare scores from tests taken prior to the September 11
terrorist attacks to scores from tests taken in the months after that
event.
When interpreting testing results, it is important to make sure that
scores are an accurate indicator of what we are trying to measure. What
was true before the terrorist attacks is now just more obvious: far too
many variables exist--including those associated with the powerful and
extenuating circumstances of our nation being attacked by terrorism--
for standardized tests to truly measure school performance.
One or more of these symptoms may indicate that a child is in distress*:
- Feeling more nervous, jumpy and irritable
- Having more stomachaches, headaches, or other physical complaints
- Greater difficulty concentrating in school (especially due to thoughts
or feelings about the disaster, or because of lack of sleep)
- Fearful behavior, especially fear of being alone, being separated
from family members, or fear that something bad will happen to a family
member
- Extreme worry that
another bombing/disaster may happen
- Loss of interest in previously preferred and enjoyable activities
* Note: As indicators of post-traumatic stress, these symptoms
should be observable as a change that's occurred since the traumatic event
occurred.
Recommended Resources
- "Children Experiencing Disasters: Prevention and Intervention"
by Annette La Greca in Handbook of Psychological Services to Children
and Adolescents (Oxford Press).
Web Sites
|