Can All Your Kids Read?
Helping kids understand—and love—the written word has
never been the exclusive task of the elementary teacher. Yet the hubbub
around instruction and motivation often stops in the early grades.
Which raises the question: What do you do when Johnny, the seventh
grader, isn't getting it?
More... |

Photo by Danny Peck
|
Also in this story...
|
|
Talk to us at NEA Today Extra!
|
Think for a moment: When was the last time you read a comic book or pored
through a slamming book of poetry? Been a while? It might not be a bad idea
to reacquaint yourself, as more and more educators are doing in an attempt
to put some spark into the reading lives of their students. With the demands
to raise reading scores front and center under the so-called No Child Left
Behind law (NCLB), many are finding a new urgency in trying to reach reluctant
or struggling readers, young and old.
And while many say testing is hardly the right incentive—no one test
can determine whether someone will be an accomplished, lifelong reader—educators
across curricula and grade levels know they all have a stake in how kids develop
as readers. After all, they say, once Johnny leaves Mrs. Murray's kindergarten
class, his ability to read will play a large part in his success or lack of
it when he shows up in eighth-grade science.
So on the eve of the kickoff of NEA's Read Across America events, NEA
Today takes a look at the latest reading trends from kindergarten through high
school. Find out how NEA members are taking the struggle out of reading—and
putting the fun back.
Reading by the Script:
What's All the Fuss About?
by Sabrina Holcomb
Photo
by Nathan Ham
|
With penalties looming under NCLB, educators are increasingly using 'scripted' reading
programs to teach budding readers, but this newest trend in reading instruction
has fast become a lightning rod for controversy.
As if sparks had hit midway through their reading lesson, the cheery kindergartners
pop up from their seats and strike an attitude. Pretending to hold a mirror
with one hand and brush their hair with the other, they sway their hips side
to side and with a touch of Southern sass chant, "Look-in' good,
look-in' good!"
It's not just comic relief. These students at Baseline Elementary School
in Little Rock, Arkansas, are looking—and sounding—good, indeed.
Their reading scores have soared in the last few years, and this jazzy cheer
is their celebration—one of many they've happily learned, courtesy
of the scripted reading program Baseline's teachers credit for the reading
turnaround. "For years, we had one of the lowest reading scores in the
district," says third-grade teacher Wilfred Dunn. "This year, we
showed the greatest gain of any school in the entire state."
For Baseline, scripted reading programs—on the rise across the country—have
been a boon, and some teachers can't sing their praises enough. Typified
by standardized instruction, formulaic lessons, and an intense focus on phonics—these
highly structured programs, say boosters, stand as the best defense against
a rising illiteracy and the demands of standardized testing.
By the Script:
The Pros and Cons
When it comes to scripted reading programs, value is definitely in the
eye of the beholder.
Supporters say scripted programs . . .
- provide consistent, reliable instruction
- provide a solid foundation for beginning readers
- are strong on phonics
- help guide beginning teachers
- require less preplanning and set-up work for teachers
- help raise test scores
Critics say scripted programs . . .
- are weak on comprehension and good literature
- are inflexible and not well-balanced
- leave no room for individualized instruction
- shortchange beginning teachers
- limit teacher choices
- lead to declining test scores in the upper grades
|
A Debate Rages
But not everyone is so enthused. Far from it. In fact, this latest trend in
reading instruction has sparked a debate so fierce that some educators question
whether kids being taught today will ever become thoughtful, discriminating
readers who can actually grasp a book's real meaning—much less
subtext.
What's the fuss about? The most fervent detractors say scripted programs
cast publishers as producers, reading coaches as directors, and teachers and
students as mere actors in someone else's play. Many complain they take
away teachers' ability to make informed, creative choices for their students. "They
take the professionalism out of the profession," says Dawn Christiana,
a reading teacher in Bellingham, Washington. "You don't have to
think; you don't have to modify; you just script." Others say the
programs are nothing more than quick fixes for school districts on a desperate
search for the Holy Grail of reading instruction—programs that raise
reading scores in time to avoid penalties under the so-called No Child Left
Behind law.
Notably, critics say, scripted programs are the ones that get the heartiest
sanction under the rules of NCLB's Reading First legislation, which only
grants federal monies to districts that use "scientific researched-based" reading
programs. Since Reading First was launched three years ago, the use of scripted
programs appears to have risen sharply and educators are taking note.
"NCLB is shaping the way reading is being taught," says John Cromshow,
a Los Angeles kindergarten teacher whose district uses a scripted program despised
widely by many of its educators. "Districts are feeling the pressure
to use scripted programs that have been sanctioned by the current administration," Cromshow
continues, noting, "There's lots of money to be made. The district
spends millions of dollars on reading coaches, conferences, and program training."
Not All Black and White
Photo
by Chris Dean
|
But there are areas of gray, and where educators position themselves in the
dispute depends a lot on how their school districts have responded to NCLB
demands. Although federal reading grants are targeted to schools that can least
afford to lose them—those with the lowest performance and/or the largest
proportion of neediest students—some districts have shunned the money
and adopted more progressive literacy programs or kept the programs they currently
use.
But where districts have complied and adopted scripted programs that have
a Reading First "good housekeeping seal of approval," the viability
of those programs, says Cathy Roller, director of Research and Policy for the
International Reading Association, has depended largely on a potpourri of local
decisions: which specific program gets chosen, the attitude of reading coaches,
the availability of extra support and, most important, the extent to which
teachers have a voice in the process.
Baseline Elementary in Little Rock, the teachers there admit, was fortunate
to have the right combination of all these factors.
A Measure of Success
Photo
by Bob Riha, Jr.
|
Even though Baseline's reading program, Success for All (SFA), is one
of the most highly scripted programs on the market, Baseline's teachers
agreed from the start that its structure was an advantage. "This program
is the right choice for the kids in our community," explains teacher
Wilfred Dunn. "It may not be right for the kids across town, but southwest
Little Rock is the 'hood.' A large percentage of our kids are in
foster care, so they don't have a stable home environment. Some come
to school without any sleep or food. Our kids have no structure in their lives;
they need the structure of this program."
Another plus: Baseline's teachers feel supported rather than "spied
on" by their literacy coach and program facilitator, Mary Jane McDonald,
unlike in other places where teachers feel put upon by coaches they bemoan
as "reading police."
"Our coach asks for our input," says Barbara Garner, a third-grade
teacher whose degree is in literacy. I don't feel Mary is critiquing
me. I feel she's monitoring how the program works." McDonald makes
sure the program is implemented according to the script but "the script
is there to familiarize teachers with the lesson," she says, "not
to be read word by word."
Photo
by Bob Riha, Jr.
|
The relationship has paid off. Four years ago, 85 percent of Baseline's
students scored below the proficient level on the state reading exam. Last
year, 85 percent scored proficient or above. Which is why teachers at Baseline
don't just love the program—"I'm obsessed with it," admits
second- grade teacher Darrel Sharp, who has been teaching for 33 years. Notes
Shantel Fells, one of Baseline's three full-time reading tutors: "I
start working with them on the Word Board on Monday and by Friday, Bam!, my
babies can read those words just like everyone else in the class."
In fact, the entire staff felt so strongly about the program that when they
were encouraged to use Arkansas Reading First—a more flexible and less
scripted program—during the 2003–04 school year, Principal Eleanor
Cox successfully advocated for the return of SFA. "Impoverished children
don't arrive here as astute grammarians," says Cox. "Their
parents send us the best they have. We work with them and by the time they
reach fourth grade, they've got a foundation."
Cox recounts the remarkable progress of one fourth-grade student who was "reading" on
a pre-K level in second grade but had caught up by fourth grade. This year,
she ran for vice president of the student council, writing and delivering her
own campaign speech. Cox admits this kind of success story would not have been
possible without the buy-in of the staff. "If you don't have collaboration," says
Cox, "you're just spinning your wheels."
A Different Perspective
It's a lesson the teachers and administrators in the Los Angeles school
district have learned all too well. In sharp contrast to Little Rock, many
teachers in Los Angeles bitterly resent Open Court, the scripted reading program
widely used throughout the district and the state.
Phoebe Conn, a kindergarten teacher at El Sereno Elementary School in Los
Angeles, describes what she sees as the main flaw in the Open Court program. "It's
boring," she says flatly. "It stifles initiative and creativity
and frustrates everyone—students and teachers. When they give the Teacher
of the Year Award, they always give it to wonderfully creative teachers. They
don't give it for reading a script—'This woman can really
read like a metronome!'—and God help us, let's hope they
never do."
"When we first piloted Open Court at my school," Conn adds, "six
experienced kindergarten teachers all turned thumbs down. It wasn't age
appropriate. It's a very slow program and four- and five-year-old children
need to be more involved in learning."
Say That in Spanish
"As hideous as Open Court is in English, just cube that in Spanish," says
outspoken bilingual kindergarten teacher Sheryl Ortega. Ortega teaches at Logan
Elementary School, where 80–90 percent of the students are English-language
learners.
When the Los Angeles school district decided to align its Spanish and English
reading programs, Ortega was asked to serve on the advisory task force, along
with 11 bilingual teachers and 11 district representatives. The task force
reviewed two programs—McGraw-Hill's Foro Abierto (the Spanish version
of Open Court) and Houghton Mifflin's Lectura. "We had four hours
to pick a series, a process that usually takes months," says Ortega.
By the end of the day, all but one member had voted for Lectura because Foro
Abierto, explains Ortega, "is a literal translation of the English program
and therefore linguistically incorrect in Spanish."
Shockingly, the committee's recommendation was rejected—mainly
because schools were already using Open Court in English. After an uproar from
bilingual teachers, the superintendent relented and allowed K–2 teachers
to use Lectura. But Foro Abierto is still used in the upper grades, and while
it's not desirable, says Ortega, "teachers have accommodated, as
they've always done, inventing their own materials to make instruction
work." When word gets around that the series is successful, "it's
in fact due to teachers' professional expertise," she says.
Test Scores: Do They Add Up?
Test results "make the grade," say supporters of scripted
reading programs.
Early studies suggested Open Court students performed better than
students taught with a literature-based curriculum. An independent
study commissioned by publisher McGraw-Hill maintained that California
schools using Open Court showed marked jumps in children's literacy
skills and significantly improved test scores compared with other programs.
The test scores are misleading, say some researchers.
One study done by Margaret Heiss Moustafa, a professor of literacy
education at California State University in Los Angeles, found that
the percentage of children scoring at or above the 50th percentile
on California's SAT 9 reading exam was significantly lower in
schools with scripted programs. Several studies have found that reading
scores started to decline in the higher grades, as comprehension skills
become increasingly important. But Siegfried Engelmann, author of the
scripted program Direct Instruction (DI), counters, "The scores
for all students—groups, not individuals—drop somewhat
after third grade no matter what type of program you're using.
When DI is well-implemented, the scores drop less than any other program
out there."
What about national vs. state scores?
Experts caution that any good news about student reading performance
must be put in a national context. For example, 80 percent of students
in a state may test proficient on the state exam, while only 20 percent
test proficient on the rigorous NAEP (National Assessment of Educational
Progress) reading assessment, which includes high-level comprehension
questions that require an in-depth understanding of the text. |
Teachers Make It Work
Although Ortega believes experienced teachers can make up for some of the
deficits in scripted programs, she worries that beginning teachers aren't
getting the training they need to provide rich, high-quality reading instruction. "We've
got hundreds of young students coming out of teacher programs at the universities," says
Ortega, "and they're only being trained how to deliver Open Court
and not how to teach."
Ortega's co-workers agree the "teacher factor" is a critical
component in the ultimate success of a scripted program. James Lopez, a fifth-grade
teacher at Logan, confesses, "I go off-script. How else will all my kids
get individual attention?" "It's more work," says fourth-grade
teacher Felix Quiñónez, whose classroom is down the hall, "but
personalized instruction has a greater impact."
Like many teachers in the higher grades, Quiñónez worries that
scripted reading programs overemphasize phonics at the cost of comprehension. "I
teach to understand," says Quiñónez, who is currently working
on his National Board Certification. "You can't have breadth with
no depth."
But Siegfried Engelmann, a professor of education at the University of Oregon
and author of the scripted program Direct Instruction, vigorously disputes
this portrayal of scripted reading programs. "Direct Instruction's
comprehension performance exceeds its decoding performance. You don't
teach comprehension through reading in the early grades; you teach comprehension
through oral instruction. "
The comprehension issue is a particular concern to critics who note the widespread
use of scripted programs in low-income, minority communities, where administrators
have felt the most pressure to raise reading scores. Many now ask: Will low-income
kids suffer in the upper grades without access to the same rich, multifaceted
reading instruction their peers currently get in more successful schools? Some
educators say there's a reason to be concerned. Studies of scripted programs
over the last five years have found that reading scores are declining in the
higher grades and that poor and minority students in some districts are as
far behind as they ever were.
The Bottom Line
When it comes to teaching Johnny to read, there's a growing consensus
among educators that no single magic bullet will lead to reading success or
failure. Many teachers believe the best reading instruction allows teachers
the flexibility to address the full spectrum of reading skills and diverse
student needs.
NCLB has created a need for reproducible reading instruction that guarantees
quick results, says NEA reading specialist Barbara Kapinus. "But in all
of our emphasis on raising test scores," she cautions, "we can't
lose sight of the fact that one score on one reading test does not equal being
able, or willing, to read."
Reaching Teens:
Back to the Future
by Thomas Grillo
How teachers are using old favorites to hook the newest generation of reluctant
adolescent readers.
Illustraton:
DigitalVision
|
Terri Kirk, a high school librarian in Paducah, Kentucky, was looking for
a way to inspire adolescent males to read more, so on a whim she asked a student
to recommend a few comics and graphic novels. Now, she says, "I can't
keep these books in the library. I can hardly check them in before they're
checked out. The kids just devour them."
For Kirk—and surprisingly, many of her colleagues across the country—pointing
students to the likes of X-Men and Elektra has been one creative, and apparently
successful, inroad into a problem many say demands out-of-the-box thinking.
Face it: Some students spend several years in school and still have trouble
reading. A recent RAND Corporation survey shows that in most states, a third
or more of the middle school students don't read "proficiently," according
to the state's own definition of that term.
Of course, middle and high school educators don't need a study to tell
them they have poor readers. But what's a teacher to do? Many feel ill-equipped
to help older non-readers, as it's in the primary grades where the perennial
fights over best strategies percolate—and where educators find most reading
research focused. But increasingly, middle school and high school educators
are crafting new approaches using everything from comic books to poetry slams
to reach and help that student who can't or won't find fun and
facts in a book.
Grant it, teachers aren't replacing Shakespeare with Spiderman. But
in an age where students are raised on images in movies, TV, video, and computer
games, educators find comics connecting with students in a way traditional
literature can't.
Maryland education officials recently announced plans to start using comics
statewide next school year, from kindergarten into high school. "You
see kids reading comic books, buying comic books, and they seem totally engrossed," Maryland
state schools Superintendent Nancy Grasmick told The Washington Post. "It
looks like there's really some potential here."
Comics aren't limited to superheroes. Art Spiegelman's Holocaust
memoir Maus, which won a Pulitzer Prize in 1992, tells in chilling detail how
his parents survived the Holocaust. There's a Maus
study guide online.
Photo
by Nathan Ham
|
Kirk's students especially like a Japanese comic form called "anime" (short
for animation) that's become wildly popular over the last few years.
Anime, known for its highly stylized and intricate artwork, spans a wide range
of topics. "The students reading anime are not poor readers," says
Kirk. "Anime comics are not easy to read because you have to read them
back to front."
Steve Replogle, himself a lifelong comic book fan, introduced Bone comics
to his Denver fourth graders nearly five years ago. The Bone series, by Jeff
Smith, tells the story of three cousins who find their way into a hidden, pre-technological
valley filled with wonderful and terrifying creatures.
"I use comics specifically to reach kids who don't like books," he
says. "I needed something cool and different that's not as intimidating
as a page of text." The response from his students? "They love
it. Some kids dive into it with a real joy. Even the kids who love books like
comics, too."
The New York City Comic Book Museum offers a comics curriculum for classroom
use at no cost. Challenging Objective Minds: An Instructional Comicbook Series,
is being used by dozens of school districts nationwide for elementary, middle,
and high school students. For more information, go to www.nyccbm.org.
Robin Brenner, a librarian at the Carey Memorial Library in Lexington, Massachusetts,
operates a graphic novel Web site with age-appropriate recommended
novels. "Many people still equate comics with trash. But the fastest
growing segment of libraries are graphic novel collections because they are
visual and engaging and reach reluctant readers," Brenner says.
Tempting Teen Readers
Hot Tips from School Librarians
When it comes to enticing teens to read, middle and high school librarians
are borrowing a page from the mega-bookstores that are the favorite new
place to "chill" for readers and non-readers alike. Members
of the American Association of School Librarians and the NEA
Library Caucus share trade secrets.
Cool Picks. "Students will listen to their peers," says
Terri Kirk at Reidland High School in Paducah, Kentucky. Stack an entire
bookshelf with student picks (just like the staff picks at Borders and
Barnes and Noble). Or attach cards with student book reviews to the bookshelf
under targeted books. Attaching Amazon.com reviews also works.
Location, Location, Location. Remember the three most important things
in real estate? "Make sure you use prime space in the library to
display good books," says Jackie Gould of Regional High School
in Mullica Hill, New Jersey. Gould worked with the school's marketing
teacher and students on a project to "sell" library books.
Their ideas: Keep new books at the circulation desk, where students can
see them as they're checking books out. Set up separate shelves
for mystery, science-fiction, and fantasy, the topics most popular with
teens. Gould also makes the most of artifacts: Last September she added
poetry and art by students to a display case of books on the events of
September 11.
The Play's the Thing. Chris Gustafson, at Whitman Middle
School in Seattle, Washington, uses reader's theater plays to introduce
books during her fall library orientation for incoming students. Students
read from scripts Gustafson has written, based on passages from books. "The
students love it," says Gustafson. "It's a fun way
to introduce them to the books they'll read during the year. Gustafson
has written three books on reader's theater for teachers and librarians.
Here's more...
Coffee Can of Probability. Another Gustafson brainstorm. She selects
50 titles that have won some sort of prize or recognition the previous
year to be the focus of a year-long reading promotion. The books, which
include a variety of genres and reading levels, are housed in a separate
bookcase with a special spine label to identify them. When a student
reads one of the books, his or her name goes in a coffee can. Two names
are drawn from the can each week and the winners receive a gift certificate
donated by a local bookstore or fast food restaurant. Winners' names
are posted on the circulation desk and published in the school bulletin.
Pump Up the Volume. Audio books can be a real help to struggling readers,
who benefit from hearing, as well as seeing, the written word. Students
can listen to books as they drive their cars back and forth to school
and work. An added benefit: listening and comprehending is a core curriculum
content standard in many states.
Give It a Face-Lift. Order new editions of old favorites. No one wants
to read grubby copies with dated book jackets and pages falling out of
the seams. Don't underestimate the power of a beautiful new book
jacket with up-to-date artwork, say librarians. |
Conventional print can also hook a student who's steered clear of reading
for years. It may just be a matter of finding something that's irresistible.
If your students can't relate to books written by John Steinbeck or
Jack London, check out Quick
Picks for Reluctant Young Adult Readers, published
by the Young Adult Library Services Association.
The notable books that made this year's list include: Sharon Flake's
Begging for Change about a teen's ambivalent feelings for her drug-addicted
father; and Nightmare, by Joan Lowery Nixon, about a 16-year-old who's
sent to a camp for underachievers where she discovers a murderer.
More than 4,000 teachers have registered at Adopt-An-Author,
a Web site that links authors and classrooms. It was founded by novelist Steve
Alten, who learned from teachers that his first thriller, MEG: A Novel of Deep
Terror, best described as Jaws meets Jurassic Park—connects with students
in a way that classics could not.
Then there's poetry, which Lynne McGrath, a seventh-grade teacher at
the Hanscom, Massachusetts, Air Force Base uses successfully to reach unwilling
readers. "Poetry engages students who don't enjoy reading because
poems are not as intimidating as text,'' she says.
McGrath introduces poetry from Shel Silverstein to Emily Dickinson. Students
write down lines they enjoy and what poems they like and dislike, and then
talk about the work.
The finale is a poetry slam where students present original poems while dressed
in black "beatnik'' style. One 13-year-old student wrote
a poem to express his crush on a girl in the classroom, recalls McGrath. "It
was modeled after Lord Byron's and began "She walks in beauty, like
the night…''
Okay, those ideas might work in English class. But what if you teach science
or social studies? Well-designed visuals and experiential learning can help,
but almost all teachers depend on the printed word to get much of the curriculum
across. So what can you do about students who can read a passage, but just
can't seem to get the idea?
Pamela Tobiczyk, along with more than 300 other teachers in Arkansas, Virginia,
and Michigan, may have found an answer with a new training program geared to
adolescents.
The Michigan Content Literacy: Assessments, Standards and Strategies (MiCLASS),
is a 24-hour training program for teachers in all content areas on strategies
for helping weak readers get more out of what they read.
"These strategies are about getting students to organize information
and think about it, not just memorize it," says NEA reading specialist
Barbara Kapinus. "In the process of organizing and reorganizing, you
think about it more deeply so you understand it better.''
Tobiczyk, a sixth-grade teacher in Clinton Township believes her students
benefit from what she learned in MiCLASS. For years, she has taught Tuck Everlasting,
Natalie Babbitt's classic novel about young Winnie Foster's choice
of whether to drink from a fountain of youth. But today she's teaching
it differently.
She used to have students answer questions about plot and setting. Now, Tobiczyk's
classroom is alive with debate about whether it's a good idea to live
forever and whether breaking the law is ever justified. (Winnie helps one character
escape from jail.)
"We still examine story elements, but I encourage debate,'' she
says. "During a heated discussion one student asked,'Why would
anyone want to live forever if their family would be dead?' Another said, 'if
you had forever, you could see the world.'"
Jon Obermeyer, a middle school special needs teacher in Roscommon, Michigan,
and a MiCLASS proponent, says the program changed his approach. "I was
always the person who gave the knowledge and I decided what they would learn.
Now, the kids are taking responsibility for their learning," he says.
NEA's Read Across America:
Is There a Doctor in the House?
by Rachael Walker
More and more Americans are choosing not to read. Which is worse? Not reading
because you can't or because you won't?
Photo
by Read Across America
|
When was the last time you picked up a book and read for your own pleasure?
Not a magazine. Not a Web page. An actual book with characters and a plot.
Can't remember when? You could be one of the millions suffering from
aliteracy.
That's aliteracy, not illiteracy. Aliteracy strikes those who can read
but choose not to. According to the National Endowment for the Arts, more than
half of America's adult population isn't reading literature, and
this malady isn't limited to adults. Aliterate students may never become
strong, fully engaged readers.
NEA's Read Across America and the March 2 birthday celebration of Dr.
Seuss provide a day of reading excitement to focus attention on reading. But
the good Doctor can't inoculate against all the ills of aliteracy, so
NEA offers a year-round calendar of activities, programs, partnerships, and
resources to help get kids of all ages wanting to read. Here are just a few
of the partners and programs that have kids reading across America all year.
Prescription for Soon-to-be Readers
Photo
by Sandy Schaeffer
|
What's the cure for children as young as two years of age who watch
more than three hours of television daily? Doctors and nurses who participate
in the Reach Out and Read (ROR) program think they've found it: regularly
prescribe reading and make sure there are books in the home. The Reach Out
and Read program trains medical providers to advise parents about the importance
of reading aloud and to give books to children at pediatric check-ups from
six months to five years of age. The more than 2,000 ROR programs throughout
the country also depend on volunteers to demonstrate the joys of reading aloud
to children by sharing books with families in pediatric waiting rooms.
Recent research shows that ROR is having direct effects on literacy development:
children are more experienced with books and have the language skills they
need for reading acquisition. Educators in the Virginia State Reading Association
have recognized the benefits ROR brings into the classroom, have adopted several
Virginia ROR sites, and are working hard to spread the word in their communities
to all doctors. Says Elli Sparks, the coordinator for the Virginia Coalition
of Reach Out and Read programs, "Educators know their communities so
well. Without their outreach, we couldn't begin to reach the doctors
whose patients can really use the ROR program. Their help in providing books,
volunteers, and funding to local clinics and hospitals ensures a regular dose
of reading for hundreds of low-income children."
Exercise for the Body, Mind, and Soul
Photo
by Charlie Welch
|
Movies and popcorn go together, kind of like teachers and classrooms. But
soccer and poetry? Sometimes it takes an unusual combination to get kids' attention.
America SCORES thinks it has found the right mix, and so do the thousands of
kids who benefit from the innovative after-school program that uses soccer
games and poetry classes to help urban students score in the classroom and
on the playground.
How does this combo work? America SCORES sets up a soccer league at a public
school. Students who sign up for the league play soccer three days a week and
get creative writing instruction the other two days from teachers who serve
as writing and soccer coaches. The rules are simple. No poetry, no soccer.
Fortunately, that's not a problem because poetry classes have become
a huge hit with the children. "The kids love it because poetry has no
parameters, there's no judgment," says Eden Mendel, national director
of Public Relations, Marketing, and Education for America SCORES. "It's
the opposite of testing. The kids are motivated and encouraged to express their
ideas and emotions when teachers have the freedom to say yes."
America SCORES—started 10 years ago by a Washington, D.C., teacher—has
grown from a local grassroots project to a nationwide program. Educators from
around the country attend an intensive 10-day workshop at the University of
Iowa where they learn new methods for using poetry as a gateway to literacy.
A Dose of Their Own Medicine
When their most important issue is what to wear to school tomorrow, picking
up a book and reading for fun doesn't always occur to middle school kids.
So it's up to teachers and parents to help these reluctant readers connect
the worlds they don't know to the worlds they do know.
Since television and the Internet are often the main pull away from books,
educators can use multimedia to help students recognize the relationships between
their culture and other communities. PBS TeacherSource can direct educators
to a wide variety of multimedia opportunities to engage students. For example,
a search for middle school and American literature leads you to the series
American Roots Music. Here they can find a video series, a teacher's
guide, and a companion Web site to talk about the diverse musical styles of
blues, gospel, traditional country, zydeco, tejano, and Native American pow-wow
and relate them to the American storytelling tradition and literature.
Infectious Reading
Photo
by Viet Youth board
|
"Readers are Leaders" is more than a catchy reading promotion
slogan—it's true! The National Endowment for the Arts reports literary
readers are more committed to their communities than those suffering from aliteracy.
They are more supportive of cultural events, visit museums, and are more than
two-and-a-half times as likely to do volunteer or charity work.
Since 2000, NEA has encouraged and celebrated literacy service by America's
young people and honored them for doing reading-related activities that benefit
others. In partnership with Youth Service America (YSA), thousands of dollars
have been awarded to student-led literacy projects through the Youth Leaders
for Literacy program.
"Being able to read makes everything else possible, including the ability
to make meaningful, lifelong contributions to your community through service," said
Steven A. Culbertson, YSA president and CEO. The Chandler High School Social
Studies Council in Chandler, Arizona, knows that's true. They paired
trained Council members with fourth graders at Galveston Elementary to help
beef up students' reading skills, teach them about citizenship, and offer
them opportunities to participate in community improvement activities.
What they found was that stronger leaders and readers emerged from both age
groups—fourth graders' interests and skills went up and high school
mentors' interest in reading grew as they shared reading and built relationships
with a younger reader.
|
Get and share more ideas about reading. Don't forget to:
- Answer
our online survey question: Do you think the use of comic books is
an effective teaching tool?
- Join
our discussion board conversation and let your colleagues in on your
best ideas to hook reluctant readers.
- Find
out more about NEA's Read Across America programs and activities.
- Tap
into a host of NEA resources on reading,including books, teaching
strategies, and more tips from school librarians.
|
|