How to Help Students Value Democracy

Many young Americans have lost faith in democracy. That’s the troubling finding of several surveys conducted over the past five years.

About half of the Gen Z participants (ages 18–25) said democracy “makes no 
difference,” according to a 2022 Penn State University survey, and nearly 30 
percent said living under a dictatorship “could be good.”

Let that sink in.

A 2025 survey by the Center for Information & Research on Civic Learning 
and Engagement (CIRCLE), at Tufts University, similarly found that a third of 
Americans ages 18–29 “do not buy into the value of democracy and show higher support for authoritarian governments.” 

Although the remaining two-thirds said they generally support democracy, they do little to engage in it.

The study found no major differences between the group that still values democracy and the group that does not in terms of age, gender, city-rural division, or even party affiliation. 

So what does influence whether or not young people value our system of 
government?

“At the top of that list is education, access, and community support,” says  Alberto Medina, a co-author of the CIRCLE report. “Of course, teachers are 
critically important to helping students understand and value democracy, but so are their peers,” he says. 

When groups of students work together to understand how our government functions and even take on problems they care about, he says, it “can help show the deeply skeptical that there is something here worth saving.”

While great social studies courses are critical for students of all ages, a student’s civic education is not limited to those classrooms. In fact, public schools—as institutions that welcome all students regardless of race, first language, family income, or abilities—can serve as living laboratories of democracy. 

It’s never too early to teach civic engagement

Here’s one way to think about it, says Stephanie Serriere, a professor of social studies education at Indiana University Columbus: “Public schools are one of the first civic spaces our children enter, and it is up to you to purposefully teach the principles of democracy,” Serriere tells her classes of future educators. 

That teaching, she says, should begin in kindergarten. 

Serriere developed her theory of “carpet-time democracy” in her years as 
an elementary school teacher, when she observed her young students’ natural interest in fairness and equity. There are many creative ways to harness those instincts, she says.

For example, when elementary age students get to discuss and decide 
classroom rules, they become tiny framers of a founding document that 
applies equally to all and guides their experience in the classroom. 

When older students identify things they wish they could change—as tweens and teens tend to do—educators can walk them through the process of inquiry. This may include polling their peers, gathering research, and using their findings to advocate for change.

Research shows that asking students to gather the perspectives of their 
peers—which is at the heart of many of these projects—can be the springboard to a lifetime of empathy, according to Serriere. That’s a necessary component in a democracy, she adds. 

q

Many students want to speak out. We can teach them how to make their 
voices heard by the right people. 

Last year, when I heard the Trump administration was cutting funding for 
libraries and museums, I started writing to my elected leaders, asking them 
to fight those cuts. I quickly realized that this could be a service-learning 
opportunity for students.

As a lunchtime activity, I teach interested students how to write strong, fact-based letter, based on a visit to a local library, where they ask an employee questions about the resources and programming they offer to the community. The students learn not only what kinds of questions to ask, but also the etiquette of conducting an informational interview. We practice at school before the real interview so they feel confident.

After they gather information about the amazing programs the library has 
for kids, teens, adults, and seniors alike, the students write to our state’s 
U.S. senators. I have a template for guidance, but encourage them to include 
a personal story that will make their letters unique. 

This project teaches students to value community resources and learn how to advocate for them.

Our state passed a law a few years ago mandating at least one semester 
of civics instruction before students leave eighth grade. It’s an incredible 
opportunity to introduce some finer points of the U.S. Constitution and 
to teach students to engage in productive dialogue.

Things can heat up in a middle school classroom very quickly, so I am 
very intentional at the beginning of the course in talking to students about 
respectful discourse. Yes, they need to learn to form an argument, but it’s just as essential for them to actively listen.

Allowing students to bring up issues and talk about what they are seeing and hearing in their world is critical. They will begin to respond to each other—it’s a beautiful thing to see—and the teacher’s role is largely to monitor and moderate.

I never get on a soapbox or make my own political views known. Instead, I ask a lot of guiding questions and give students practice in finding evidence from primary sources.

Last year, for example, my students had a lot of concerns about immgration. So we went back and read the 14th Amendment to the Constitution before we started the conversation. This strategy helps students learn to support  their arguments with evidence rather than emotion. 

The energy really builds in my classes when we talk about campaigns, 
elections, and voting. 

We’re living in politically charged times, and certainly in Florida there are vague and threatening policies that make educators think twice. But as a political science professor, teaching these topics is essential to 
my students’ education. 

In my honors American government class last year, I “ran for office” as a candidate from a fictional party and asked my students to be my campaign team. 

They ran with it. The next thing you know, they are running social media platforms, having me sit for photo shoots, and polling their peers to determine my campaign priorities and slogans. 

Once they were on a roll, I threw them some curveballs. When big things 
happened in the real world, I asked them how I, in my role as the candidate, 
should respond. 

I tell my students, ”You can know everything there is to know about American government, but if you don’t do anything with that knowledge, you’re giving up your role in shaping the society you live in."